Skip to content
Lyfrox

Coaching is not what you do when someone is failing

Coaching is the leader's use of one-to-one developmental dialogue, structured around the team member's own goals, to raise their self-awareness, performance and capacity to solve problems independently. What the evidence says, what high and low look like in practice, and where to start.

Lyfrox Leadership practice · Leadership · 26 October 2026

What we mean by coaching

Coaching is the leader's use of one-to-one developmental dialogue, structured around the team member's own goals, to raise their self-awareness, performance and capacity to solve problems independently (Grant, 2003; Whitmore, 1992).

The dimension covers the quality and regularity of the leader's developmental conversations: asking rather than telling, giving specific behavioural feedback, helping people set and pursue their own goals, and adjusting support to the individual. It is about the leader's manner of working with each person, not the design of the team's skills. It excludes identifying skill gaps, assigning stretch work and building the team's collective capability, which belong to Capability Building; coaching is the conversation, Capability Building is the curriculum. It also excludes reviewing progress against delivery commitments, which is Accountability, although the same meeting may contain both.

Why it matters

Workplace coaching has a credible evidence base. Jones, Woods and Guillaume's (2016) meta-analysis of 17 studies found a positive overall effect on organisational outcomes (d = .36), with larger effects for skill and performance outcomes and, notably, comparable or larger effects when coaching was delivered by internal coaches, including line managers, rather than external ones. Theeboom, Beersma and van Vianen (2014) reported significant effects on performance and skills (g = .60), wellbeing (g = .46), coping (g = .43), work attitudes (g = .54) and goal-directed self-regulation (g = .74). Grant's (2003) early controlled study shows the mechanism: goal-focused coaching improved goal attainment and metacognition while reducing depression, anxiety and stress.

Whether managers actually coach depends on beliefs and skill more than time. Heslin, Vandewalle and Latham (2006) showed that managers who believe ability is malleable coached a struggling employee more and better than those who do not, and that a brief intervention shifting those beliefs increased subsequent coaching. The feedback component is double-edged: Kluger and DeNisi's (1996) meta-analysis found feedback improved performance on average (d = .41) but worsened it in over a third of cases, particularly when it drew attention to the self rather than the task. A leader who coaches well therefore keeps feedback specific and task-focused and treats the team member's own goals as the organising frame.

What it looks like when it is strong

  • Holds regular one-to-ones that begin with the team member's agenda rather than a status update
  • Asks "what have you already tried?" and "what would you do if I were not here?" before offering a solution
  • Gives feedback within days of the event, describing the behaviour and its effect rather than the person
  • Helps each team member set one or two development goals and returns to them in subsequent conversations
  • Varies approach by person: directive with a novice on a new task, exploratory with an experienced colleague

What it looks like when it is low

Where to start

  • Open your next one-to-one with "what is most useful for us to talk about?" and hold task review until the last ten minutes
  • For one week, count how often you answer versus ask when a team member brings a problem; aim to reverse the ratio for the next week
  • Give one piece of specific, task-focused feedback to each team member within 48 hours of observing the behaviour
  • Ask each person for one development goal they own, write it down, and return to it at every second one-to-one
  • Set a maximum span of control at which regular one-to-ones are feasible, and treat breaches as a structural issue
  • Train managers in coaching through practice and observation, including a session on beliefs about whether people change

References

  • Jones, R. J., Woods, S. A. & Guillaume, Y. R. F. (2016). The effectiveness of workplace coaching: A meta-analysis of learning and performance outcomes from coaching. Journal of Occupational and Organizational Psychology, 89(2), 249–277. — Meta-analysis showing positive effects of workplace coaching, including when delivered by internal coaches
  • Theeboom, T., Beersma, B. & van Vianen, A. E. M. (2014). Does coaching work? A meta-analysis on the effects of coaching on individual level outcomes in an organizational context. The Journal of Positive Psychology, 9(1), 1–18. — Effects on performance, wellbeing, coping, attitudes and self-regulation
  • Grant, A. M. (2003). The impact of life coaching on goal attainment, metacognition and mental health. Social Behavior and Personality, 31(3), 253–264. — Early controlled study linking goal-focused coaching to goal attainment and mental health
  • Heslin, P. A., Vandewalle, D. & Latham, G. P. (2006). Keen to help? Managers' implicit person theories and their subsequent employee coaching. Personnel Psychology, 59(4), 871–902. — Managers' beliefs about malleability predict coaching quality and can be changed
  • Kluger, A. N. & DeNisi, A. (1996). The effects of feedback interventions on performance: A historical review, a meta-analysis, and a preliminary feedback intervention theory. Psychological Bulletin, 119(2), 254–284. — Feedback helps on average but harms in a third of cases; task focus matters

Drawn from the Lyfrox Leadership Effectiveness Framework, stewarded by the Leadership practice.